In the vast majority of contact sports, the use of a mouthguard is strongly recommended, and most sports where there is a chance of collision will outright require that all athletes wear suitable dental protection.
There are a lot of reasons for this; besides not wanting to lose teeth or have them broken, which as happened to boxer Mike McTigue can cause not only health concerns but competitive disadvantages, but there are also suggestions that it can help reduce the risk of concussions and head injuries.
However, the first known use of a mouthguard, like so many safety developments, caused a controversy that seems bewildering looking back.
The Gum Shield And The Kid
Born Gershon Mendeloff, Ted “Kid” Lewis was one of the first British boxers to be successful in the United States, one of the youngest boxing world champions ever and having competed in nearly 300 fights.
Beyond being exceptionally skilled and prolific in the ring, he was also a pioneer, being believed to be the first professional athlete to ever wear a mouthpiece, although with record keeping being poor from that era, it is impossible to confirm this.
Mr Lewis was a friend of Phillip Krause, who had carried on his father Woolf’s work in creating a reusable mouthpiece that provided some rudimentary protection for teeth.
The elder Mr Krause used gutta-percha resin, most commonly used now in root canal procedures, and would lay strips of it over the top and bottom of the teeth.
The younger Mr Krause, himself an amateur boxer, managed to turn that into a mouthpiece that could be used more than once using rubber as the main material.
As well as inventing it, this would mean that Phillip Krause was also the first person to use a custom-built mouthguard rather than one that has been somewhat haphazardly put together using other materials.
Where it became controversial was on 7th February 1921 in a fight at Madison Square Garden in New York City between “Kid” and his most famous rival, the local “Boxing Marvel” Jack Britton.
The two boxers had an exceedingly long history, with over 20 fights over six years and a total of 224 rounds of fighting. It has been claimed whenever one man heard the other’s name, they physically winced recalling the memories of their battles.
This fight, which would ultimately be their last together, saw “Kid” Lewis wear a mouthguard against the reigning Welterweight Champion of the World, protecting himself slightly for what would inevitably be a very long fight.
However, chaos ensued after just two rounds, as Mr Britton took Mr Lewis back to his corner and both the former and his manager complained that the gum shield was giving him an advantage.
The referee agreed and told him to take it out. Ultimately, Mr Britton would win the fight by unanimous decision, but that was not the end of the ramifications.
Four days later, the New York State Athletic Commission banned mouthguards as a violation of the Walker Law which governed boxing at the time.
This turned out to have gruesome consequences for Mike McTigue, and by 1930 it was legal and expected for boxers to wear mouthguards, with other contact sports following suit.
